Tuesday, July 1, 2014

Rigor in Education




Below are two article summaries, which are connected by people's misguidedness of how "rigorous" a child's education should be.

Trinity is fortunate in that--by and large--there is agreement from most parents and teachers that kids at Trinity learn best without stress/pressure and that a vital outcome of a Trinity education is continued student excitement and engagement in learning.

While parents—myself included--generally want their children to be in the sweet spot--the proper balance of challenge and competence in the zone of proximal development (I still remember a few things from my graduate education classes!), we also kind of want our kids pushed beyond this sweet spot—and as a result, we can fall into the misguided assumption that if there's no pain, there's no gain. 

Through my years in the classroom and as an administrator, I have had hundreds of meetings with parents about their child not being pushed and challenged enough. (Once I had a parent tell me that I was doing a bad job teaching his daughter because she looked forward to coming to school.) While these conversations have been less frequent at Trinity, I a realist enough to know that this issue can surface anytime and in any grade. 

Coincidentally, yesterday Dawn, Rhonda, and I had a parent meeting with 3s and PreK and we heard that a number of parents were going to bring up this topic. At the beginning of the meeting I spoke about the reasoning and rationale of play-based learning and imaginative, creative play and its connection to brain development. When we finally brought up the topic of "rigor and academics" all the parents had a better sense of not only Trinity's philosophy but the research that supports it—and all they did was compliment our program and approach to learning.

Not all meetings go this way, yet I think the more we can provide the reasoning, rationale, and research for what we know is in the best interest of kids and their learning, the more parents (most of them) will understand and support us.

We are fortunate to be in an elementary-only environment, yet the trickle down demand for more rigor, sedentary school work, and homework can easily slip through Trinity's front gate. 

Enjoy the weekend!

Joe

What’s the ‘Sweet Spot’ of Difficulty For Learning?

Should we be making learning easier for kids—or harder?

The answer, according to research in cognitive science and psychology, is both.

First, let’s think about how and why we might make learning easier. This has to do with what psychologists call “cognitive load”— the amount of information we have to keep in mind as we solve a problem. Decades of research has shown that this capacity is quite limited.

Harvard psychologist George Miller famously said that we could keep seven pieces of information in our minds at a time (he called it “the magic number seven”), but he was looking at studies that used numbers or letters or simple symbols. When the pieces of information are more complex, like concepts or facts, the number of them that we can keep in mind goes down, to about four. And if we are actively manipulating or combining those pieces of information, as we do in most kinds of real-life problem-solving, the number of things our minds can hang on to drops even further, to maybe two or three.

The problem is that many tasks we ask students to do impose too great a cognitive load. They lose track of what they’re doing, they make mistakes, they get lost and give up. Even if they hang on long enough to solve the problem, they don’t have enough mental capacity left over to reflect on what they’ve done — and reflection is where learning really happens.

So: the way in which we should make learning easier is to reduce cognitive load, especially when we are introducing new or complicated materials. Break complicated ideas into smaller pieces, taking them one at a time. Offer lots of opportunities for practice with feedback. Avoid using jargon and other technical terms. Eliminate extraneous or distracting information and focus only on what the learner needs to know at this moment.

What about making learning harder? Is there ever a reason to do that? Yes, and the reason is twofold. 

The first reason to make learning harder is to make it interesting. Learning something new and complicated is hard in itself, as we saw above. Lightening the learner’s cognitive load will allow her to learn more effectively without becoming frustrated or confused.

But once the learner has attained some degree of mastery, ratcheting up the difficulty will help her stay in her “sweet spot” of engagement, where the task is not too hard as to be frustrating and not so easy as to be boring. This is also the place where learners can practice encountering adversity and challenge and overcoming them, a key experience in the development of grit.

The second reason to make learning harder is that it makes learning work better. UCLA psychologist Robert Bjork has developed the idea of “desirable difficulties”—difficulties that we actually want to introduce into students’ learning to make it more effective. Bjork notes that many of the learning activities that make students feel competent and successful—like reading over a textbook passage several times so that it feels familiar—actually do very little to help them learn. What they should do instead is something like this: close that textbook and ask themselves to recall from memory what they’ve just read.

It won’t feel as good. They’ll struggle to remember the words that were just in front of their eyes. But this activity, known as retrieval practice (or simply self-testing) is an example of a desirable difficulty that will dramatically increase students’ learning. You can read more about desirable difficulties here, in an article by Bjork himself.

The Disturbing Transformation of Kindergarten

One of the most distressing characteristics of education reformers is that they are hyper-focused on how students perform, but they ignore how students learn. Nowhere is this misplaced emphasis more apparent, and more damaging, than in kindergarten.

A new University of Virginia study found that kindergarten changed in disturbing ways from 1999-2006. There was a marked decline in exposure to social studies, science, music, art and physical education and an increased emphasis on reading instruction. Teachers reported spending as much time on reading as all other subjects combined.

The time spent in child-selected activity dropped by more than one-third. Direct instruction and testing increased. 

Moreover, more teachers reported holding all children to the same standard.

How can teachers hold all children to the same standards when they are not all the same? They learn differently, mature at different stages – they just are not all the same especially at the age of 4-6.

Is this drastic shift in kindergarten the result of a transformation in the way children learn? No! A 2011 nationwide study by the Gesell Institute for Child Development found that the ages at which children reach developmental milestones have not changed in 100 years.

For example, the average child cannot perceive an oblique line in a triangle until age 5 1Ž2. This skill is a prerequisite to recognizing, understanding and writing certain letters. The key to understanding concepts such as subtraction and addition is “number conservation.” A child may be able to count five objects separately but not understand that together they make the number five. The average child does not conserve enough numbers to understand subtraction and addition until 51Ž2 or 6.

If we teach reading, writing, subtraction and addition before children are ready, they might memorize these skills, but will they will not learn or understand them. And it will not help their achievement later on

Child development experts understand that children must learn what their brains are ready to absorb. Kindergarten is supposed to set the stage for learning academic content when they are older. If they are going to push our kindergarten children to move faster, what does that say for the push for “educating” Pre-K?

Play is essential in kindergarten – in fact in any child under the age of 5. Through play, children build literacy skills they need to be successful readers. By speaking to each other in socio-dramatic play, children use the language they heard adults read to them or say. This process enables children to find the meaning in those words.

Two major studies confirmed the value of play vs. teaching reading skills to young children. Both compared children who learned to read at 5 with those who learned at 7 and spent their early years in play-based activities. Those who read at 5 had no advantage. Those who learned to read later had better comprehension by age 11, because their early play experiences improved their language development.

Yet current educational policy banishes play in favor of direct instruction of inappropriate academic content and testing; practices that are ineffective for young children.

The No Child Left Behind Law played a major role in changing kindergarten. Upper-grade curricula were pushed down in a mistaken belief that by learning reading skills earlier, children would fare better on standardized tests. 
The UVA study found that in schools with the highest percentage of children of color and children eligible for free-and-reduced-priced lunch, teachers had the most demanding expectations for student performance.

It may satisfy politicians to see children perform inappropriately difficult tasks like trained circus animals. However, if we want our youngest to actually learn, we will demand the return of developmentally appropriate kindergarten.

Student Engagement



The longer I am in education the more convinced I am that the most important outcome of education is fostering in students the same innate curiosity they brought to school as preschoolers.

Unfortunately, too often the outcome of education gets reduced to scores on tests like ERB, SSAT, SAT, ACT, AP. (I was talking with a educator from Britain earlier this week who said he liked teaching in here in the U.S. but was getting frustrated with government influence in education. Move to independent schools I told him.)

In a previous article summary post, I mentioned that kids become disengaged from school as early as 3d grade.
The article summary below provides research on effective teaching techniques that foster engagement in high school students.

As I read the article I thought both of the ways I had (and hadn't) engaged my students in the classroom and which teachers I best connected with when I was a student and why.

We in education often try to complicate good teaching with fancy terms, etc., yet to me good teaching is always more about getting to know students as "real people" and just as importantly having them know you as a real person with interests, dislikes, etc.

Enjoy the weekend!

Joe

----------

Eliciting Engagement in the High School Classroom

Student engagement (versus boredom) is a key correlate of success in high school, and some teachers are much more successful at engaging their students than others.

The research so far haven’t given us a clear idea of how to increase engagement across a school.

There are three types of student engagement:
  • Behavioral: the extent to which a student listens, does assignments, follows directions, participates
  • Cognitive: the extent to which a student applies mental energy, thinks about the content, tries to figure out new material, and grapples with mental challenges
  • Emotional: the extent to which a student enjoys a class, feels comfortable and interested, and wants to do well.
These three dimensions interact in a synergistic way, but the emotional dimension may be the most important, driving the other two.

This is because it’s all tied up with adolescents’ identity development – the process of integrating successes, failures, routines, habits, rituals, novelties, thrills, threats, violations, gratifications, frustrations into a coherent and evolving interpretation of who we are.

Identity development could be an underlying mechanism by which adolescents subconsciously make meaning of classroom experiences and then engage or disengage accordingly.

Three classroom approaches seem to work best to get students engaged:

Connective instruction: Making personal connections to the subject matter through six teaching practices: helping students see the relevance of academic content to their lives, cultures, and futures; conveying caring for students at an academic, social, and personal level; demonstrating understanding of students; providing affirmation through praise, written feedback, and opportunities for success; using humor; and enabling self-expression by having students share ideas, opinions, and values with others.

Academic rigor: Emphasizing the academics of a class via three teaching practices: providing challenging work; “academic press” (emphasis on hard work and academic success); and conveying passion for the content.

Lively teaching: Replacing tedious lectures and low-involvement videos with three perkier teaching practices: using games and fun activities (such as academic Jeopardy and Family Feud); having students work in cooperative groups; and assigning hands-on projects.

Connective instruction practices were seven times more effective at fostering student engagement than academic rigor and lively teaching, with lively teaching by itself coming in last. The key is tapping into students’ identity development. Through emphasizing relational connections between students and their teachers, content, and learning experiences connective instruction practices appear to draw on students’ sense of self as a mechanism for engagement.



Confidence on Men and Women and Its Implication for Elementary School


Below is a fascinating article summary from "The Confidence Gap" in May issue of The Atlantic, May 2014 

The summary quotes are longer than usual because there is a lot of interesting information here—both from a personal and professional standpoint.

As I read the article, I kept thinking of the different ways my wife and I approach situations and issues and to what extent our gender and our self-confidence influence our actions. As the article highlights, my wife is confident only when she feels she is perfect while I possess what the authors deem “honest overconfidence” in which me like me believe they’re better than they actually are.

The article also provides great recommendations for how we as elementary school teacher can develop confidence in girls.

Joe
---------------
For years, women have believed that with enough hard work, our natural talents would be recognized and rewarded. And indeed, women have made tremendous gains: they are half the American workforce, earn more than half of college and graduate degrees, and are increasing their share of leadership roles in many fields. Yet, as we’ve worked, ever diligent, the men around us have continued to get promoted faster and be paid more.

What’s going on? Childrearing is part of the answer. So are cultural and institutional barriers to female success. But another contributing factor is women’s acute lack of confidence. And this is true of even the most highly accomplished women we have interviewed. Compared to men, women don’t consider themselves as ready for promotions, they predict they’ll do worse on tests, and they generally underestimate their abilities.

In one study, male and female college students took a quiz on science reasoning and scored virtually the same – 7.9 and 7.5 out of 10, respectively. Before they took the test, students were asked whether they were good at science: men rated themselves 7.6 on a 10-point scale, women rated themselves 6.5. Asked how they thought they would do on the quiz, men said 7.1, women 5.8. After the quiz (before they were told the results), students were invited to participate in a science competition for prizes: 71 percent of the men signed up – and only 49 percent of the women.

A similar finding emerged from a study at Hewlett Packard of employees applying for promotions: women applied only when they met 100 percent of the qualifications; men applied if they met 60 percent. Underqualified and underprepared men don’t think twice about leaning in. Overqualified and overprepared, too many women still hold back. Women feel confident only when they are perfect. Or practically perfect. Along with perfectionism go other tendencies: taking the blame when things go wrong, crediting luck or other people’s help when they succeed, concluding that they’re not good enough when they hit a rough patch, and avoiding risks.

Do men doubt themselves sometimes? Of course. But not with such exacting and repetitive zeal, and they won’t let their doubts stop them as often as women do. Men tend to possess “honest overconfidence” – they really believe they’re better than they actually are, which is why they don’t alienate people by coming across as arrogant or overconfident.
And this trait pays dividends in life: it turns out that confidence matters as much as competence. Within any given organization, be it an investment bank or the PTA, some individuals tend to be more admired and more listened to than others. They are not necessarily the most knowledgeable or capable people in the room, but they are the most self-assured – manifested in expansive body language, a calm, relaxed manner, and speaking early and often. For decades women have misunderstood an important law of the professional jungle. It’s not enough to keep one’s head down and plug away, checking items off a list. Having talent isn’t merely about being competent; confidence is a part of that talent. You have to have it to excel.

What explains the deficit of female confidence? There are some brain and hormonal differences that seem to tilt males toward risk-taking, conflict, and aggression – and females toward relationships, worrying, and dwelling on past negative experiences. But recent research on brain plasticity raises the chicken-and-egg question: is it nature or is it nurture? To explore the role of nurture, here are three arenas where confidence may be encouraged – or discouraged:

The elementary classroom:  It’s well-established that girls begin school with some developmental advantages over boys: they have longer attention spans, more-developed verbal and fine-motor skills, and are more socially adept. School is where many girls are first rewarded for being good, instead of energetic, rambunctious, or even pushy. Soon they learn that they are most valuable, and most in favor, when they do things the right way: neatly and quietly. In turn, they begin to crave the approval they get for being good. There’s certainly no harm intended by overworked, overstressed teachers (or parents). Who doesn’t want a kid who works hard and doesn’t cause a lot of trouble?

But the result is that many girls are learning to avoid taking risks and making mistakes – and mistakes are essential to building confidence. Stanford social psychologist Carol Dweck noticed that boys get eight times more criticism than girls in elementary classrooms. Boys get a lot more scolding and punishment, but it’s less damaging because of the way many adults express it: Boys’ mistakes are attributed to a lack of effort, while girls come to see mistakes as a reflection of their deeper qualities. Girls are praised for being perfect, and this comes back to haunt them when they mess up.

The playground: Boys also benefit from the rough-and-tumble of unstructured play. From kindergarten on they roughhouse, tease one another, point out one another’s limitations, and call one another morons and slobs. Many learn to let derogatory remarks slide off their backs and they become more resilient.

The sports field: Girls who play team sports are more likely to graduate from college, find jobs in male-dominated fields, and earn bigger salaries. But despite Title IX, girls are still not participating in athletics as much as boys, and they are nearly six times as likely to drop out of sports teams, especially during adolescence.

What a vicious circle: girls lose confidence, so they quit competing, thereby depriving themselves of one of the best ways to regain it. They leave school crammed full of interesting historical facts and elegant Spanish subjunctives, proud of their ability to study hard and get the best grades, and determined to please. But somewhere between the classroom and the cubicle, the rules change, and they don’t realize it. They slam into a work world that doesn’t reward them for perfect spelling and exquisite manners. And their confidence takes another beating.

What often happens when women do display confidence in the classroom and the workplace. Attitudes toward women are changing, and for the better, but a host of troubling research shows that they can still pay a heavier social and even professional penalty than men do for acting in a way that’s seen as aggressive. If a woman walks into her boss’s office with unsolicited opinions, speaks up first at meetings, or gives business advice above her pay grade, she risks being disliked or even – let’s be blunt – being labeled a bitch. The more a woman succeeds, the worse the vitriol seems to get. It’s not just her competence that’s called into question; it’s her very character. Which is why many accomplished women play down their competence and power – while men in similar positions tend to do the opposite.

Despite some early doubts, we believe all this can be changed. Confidence is not, as we once believed, just feeling good about yourself. A better definition of confidence comes from State University psychologist Richard Petty: Confidence is the stuff that turns thoughts into action. It turns thoughts into judgments about what we’re capable of doing, which affects the ability to execute. This suggests a “virtuous circle: Confidence is a belief in one’s ability to succeed, a belief that stimulates action. In turn, taking action bolsters one’s belief in one’s ability to succeed. So confidence accumulates – through hard work, through success, and even through failure.

There has been interesting research by University of Warwick psychologist Zachary Estes on men’s and women’s performance reorganizing 3-D images on a computer screen. When first tested, women did much worse than men, but when Estes looked at the data, he noticed that women hadn’t attempted many of the puzzles – they’d given up. He ran the test again, this time telling everyone that they had to at least attempt every puzzle. This time the women did just as well as the men. The experiment illustrates a key point. The natural result of low confidence is inaction. When women don’t act, when we hesitate because we aren’t sure, we hold ourselves back. But when we do act, even if it’s because we were forced to, we perform just as well as men do.

Estes then conducted two other experiments. First, he gave men and women different puzzles and asked them before they attempted each one how confident they felt about having the correct solution. Women’s scores dropped to 75 percent while men’s rose to 93. One little nudge asking women how sure they are about something rattles their world while the same gesture reminds men that they’re terrific.

These results could not be more relevant to understanding the confidence gap, and figuring out how to close it. What doomed the women in Estes’s lab was not their actual ability to do well on the tests. They were as able as the men were. What held them back was the choice they made not to try. The advice implicit in such findings is hardly unfamiliar: to become more confident, women need to stop thinking so much and just act… If we keep at it, if we channel our talent for hard work, we can make our brains more confidence-prone. What the neuroscientists call plasticity, we call hope.

Summer and Reflection



As we transition into summer mode, below are two lists of the best books on education.



I’ve read a bunch of them, heard about others, and am unfamiliar with some.

Summer is a great time for educators to relax and re-energize. But it’s also a great time to reflect on our educational beliefs and practices.

At last week’s end-of-year faculty/staff meeting, I talked about where Trinity places itself on the innovative—traditional continuum. I neglected to mention that the key word is continuum—in other words, there is no school that is completely innovative or traditional. Our challenge as teachers is to constantly evaluate where we are on the continuum and to frequently re-adjust when we find ourselves moving too far in either direction.

I know we all have selected summer reads from our list and will discuss and share their contents at pre-planning, yet take a look at these lists—maybe you will be inspired to read a couple of them, and they, in turn, will influence you and your educational philosophy and teaching.

Two books on the lists that have influenced me and my educational philosophy are Daniel Willingham’s Why Students Don’t Like School and Diane Ravitch’s The Death and Life of the Great American School System. The first one provides evidence from cognitive science of basic questions and issues we all grapple with as teachers. The second is how Ravitich moved from being an educational conservative, e.g., data driven, standardized test supporter, to a more whole-child advocate who now rails against the “rigor” wrought by No Child Left Behind legislation.

A book not on the list but one I recommend is The Good School by Peg Tyre which focuses on qualities parents need to look for in a great school.

I hope all of you have a wonderful summer. Thank you for a great school year!

Joe