As an elementary school, Trinity has many goals for our students, including helping them become increasingly confident in their abilities, responsible of their actions, and independent in thought and action.
The article below describes how one elementary teacher intentionally designed classroom routines and expectations to foster greater student independence. She noticed that her students’ first impulse was to come to her for almost everything. They raised their hands constantly and asked questions about things she believed they were capable of figuring out or managing on their own.
Early in my teaching career, educational consultant and psychologist Robert Evans influenced my thinking on this issue. He emphasized that, much like parents, teachers should not do for a child what the child can do for him/herself.
What I particularly like about this article is the teacher’s recognition that fostering independence often begins with seemingly mundane aspects of classroom life. She made adjustments to her classroom environment and established routines that gave students more responsibility for common situations: knowing when they could use the bathroom, figuring out how to line up and transition, and accessing the supplies they needed.
As students became more comfortable handling these everyday situations independently, the teacher noticed something else: their confidence in the academic work of the classroom grew as well. They became more willing to tackle challenges on their own and gradually stopped seeing the teacher as their first option whenever they were stuck or had a question.
Not every strategy described in the article will be appropriate for every classroom or every child. The larger message, however, is an important one for all of us: Are we intentionally creating opportunities for our students to practice independence?
Sometimes, helping children become more independent means stepping back just enough to allow them to figure something out for themselves.
Joe
---
In my elementary classroom, I learned early that student independence doesn’t happen by chance—it’s built into the structure of the classroom management plan. When that structure is intentional, students stop waiting for permission at every turn and start solving small problems on their own.
There was a time when I didn’t really notice how often I was being asked for things students could easily handle themselves. Nothing big, just constant small things: Where are the pencils? What do I do next? Can I go to the bathroom? Where does this go?
None of it felt like a problem in the moment. But it added up fast, taking my attention away from instruction and leaving students waiting around for answers instead of taking action.
I wanted to figure out a way to stop being the first stop for every student question and allow students to take more initiative, building their independence into how the classroom was run.
DESIGNING THE ROOM SO THAT STUDENTS DON’T HAVE TO WAIT: One of the first shifts I made was simple. I stopped handing out basic supplies. Instead, I set up a central supply station—pencils, paper, scissors, anything we used regularly. Then, when a student raised their hand to say they needed something, instead of giving it to them, I paused to show the entire class the supply station. I explained that they should just calmly and quietly get up from their seat, get what they need, and return to their work. Once students recognized that they could move independently in the space, as long as they did so appropriately, they were able to more quickly. This helped students feel more independent and also helped me stay focused on my instruction, as it reduced the number of hands going up asking for supplies during a lesson.
MOVEMENT WITHOUT CONSTANT CHECKING IN: Next, I wanted to focus on transitions in and out of the classroom. I found that my students would wait to ask if they could go to the bathroom or get something from their lockers. While in theory this made sense, it led to a lot of wasted time, as students stopped paying attention to a lesson and just waited to ask me to take care of their needs. I introduced the whiteboard system to students: If they needed to go to the bathroom, get some water, or go to their lockers, they didn’t have to ask. They just had to sign out on the whiteboard with their name and where they were going. I also explained that only one person could be out of the room at a time and that the expectation was that students would return as quickly as possible. If you have students who abuse the system, you can use that as a teaching opportunity and let students know that they will have to revert to asking if they cannot demonstrate responsible use of the opportunity to be more independent. However, I’ve found that most students are able to handle the system well, as they are excited to be given more autonomy for how they handle their needs throughout the day.
SHIFTING HELP AWAY FROM ME: In many classrooms, students immediately ask their teacher when they need help, or they wait for their teacher to come over to them for support when they get stuck. Not only does this make it hard on a teacher to give everyone the support they need, but also it quietly trains students to just wait for help instead of trying to be more independent and seek out answers on their own. To combat this, students have to check with at least two classmates before coming to me with a question. It took some time for students to get better at asking and answering questions for one another, but once they did, it was amazing to see them collaborate and support one another rather than just wait for my help.
A CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT PLAN YOU CAN BUILD SLOWLY: When I look at all of this together, the biggest shift was simple: I wasn’t in the middle of everything anymore. Students were able to solve more small issues before they became lesson interruptions. If you’re thinking about your own classroom, you don’t need to overhaul everything. Start with one question: Where am I currently the step between a student noticing something and solving it? Then pick one small shift. Can students access materials without asking? Can movement be self-managed? Can students check with peers before coming to you? Over time, you’ll see that your students won’t have to stop learning every time something small comes up. They can just handle it and keep going. That’s the point of this kind of classroom management plan: not control or compliance, but building students’ independence by giving them opportunities to practice every day.
